Our Little Secret

After discovering their significant others are siblings, two resentful exes must spend Christmas under one roof — while hiding their romantic history.

• 
  Stephen Herek
• 
  Tamara Hansen

• 
  Lindsay Lohan
  Avery
• 
  Ian Harding
  Logan
• 
  Kristin Chenoweth
  Erica
• 
  Jon Rudnitsky
  Cameron
• 
  Dan Bucatinsky
  Leonard
• 
  Jake Brennan
  Callum
• 
  Judy Reyes
  Margaret
• 
  Katie Baker
  Cassie
• 
  Tim Meadows
  Stan
• 
  Ash Santos
  Sophie
• 
  Henry Czerny
  Mitchell
• 
  Bobbie Eakes
  Cheryl
• 
  Brian Unger
  Paul
• 
  Chris Parnell
  Veterinarian
• 
  Melinda Tanner
  Ida
• 
  Mim Drew
  Susan
• 
  Kurt Yue
  Priest
• 
  Nathan Alexander Tutterrow
  Altar Boy
• 
  Jade Fernandez
  Holly
• 
  Kimberly Donyale
  Middle Aged Woman